The Case for Retirement Communities

29 Nov 2021 | Jane Shaw

Raleigh, N.C.

If you watch TV channels that appeal to older people, you see many ads stressing the value of remaining in one’s home as one ages. The ads market the people and services that make staying in your home possible.

But is staying home the best idea as you age? In early 2017 my husband and I moved into an upscale retirement center here in Raleigh. He was experiencing some memory loss, and we wanted life to be more settled—especially since at some point we would cut back on traveling and going out.

The experience has been mixed but generally a good one. At a retirement center, for example, your friends are close by. This was important during the depths of Covid-19, when we were not allowed to go out even to shop and our meals were brought to us. A small group on our floor met once a week for wine and snacks. (I’m not sure we were supposed to do even that, but it gave us a boost.)

Yes, a retirement home has some resemblance to a college dorm. But that’s a good thing. Unlike a typical apartment complex, where one rarely knows one’s neighbors, a retirement home allows meeting many people—at meals, exercise classes, lectures and clubs.

Having a gym and a restaurant downstairs makes life easier. You can be as active as you wish (although you pay for activities you may not indulge in). And unlike a college dorm, a retirement complex is full of people who have experienced long, interesting lives. This complex has many retired professors, teachers, physicians, engineers and business executives. There are always opportunities for good conversation.

Emptying the contents of one’s home and selling it are poignant experiences, and I understand why people want to avoid them. But putting off the process, leaving it to one’s children, may not be the right approach. A one- or two-bedroom apartment (plus storage space) in a retirement home actually can hold a lot of favorite artworks and personal treasures. In fact, as time goes on, we have found we don’t really need all that we did bring.

A retirement home can succeed only if it has caring staff who tolerate the foibles of older people. I have never been reprimanded or even chided here, even though I’ve done some stupid things (and frequently forget to push the button each morning that assures I am all right). The staff’s affection for us is visible.

Similarly, one source of camaraderie among residents is the acceptance of our foibles. A retirement center is a place where you don’t have to pretend to be smarter or younger than you are. You can relax.

And the end of life takes place here. When it happened to my husband this month, I learned there are many people here who can ease the heartache. The notes, the hugs, the gifts, the get-togethers—all reminded me that nearly five years ago my husband and I did, indeed, find our home.

Mrs. Stroup is a retired nonprofit executive. Her husband was the economist Richard L. Stroup.

View the original article on the Wall Street Journal website.

John C. Goodman is President of the Goodman Institute and Senior Fellow at The Independent Institute. His books include the soon-to-be-published updated edition of Priceless: Curing the Healthcare Crisis, the widely acclaimed A Better Choice: Healthcare Solutions for America, and New Way to Care: Social Protections that Put Families First. The Wall Street Journal and National Journal, among other media, have called him the “Father of Health Savings Accounts.”