The ‘Downward Mobility’ of Struggling Young Baby Boomers

30 Jul 2026 | Jane Shaw, What's New

Gen Z passengers ride the subway in the New York, February 2024. Richard B. Levine/Zuma Press


You’ve probably heard that Generation Z—whose members are now between 14 and 29—is having a hard time.

By all accounts, these self-absorbed and overcredentialed but undereducated youths are struggling. They have a hard time finding good jobs, and when they do, many are remote. They fear the uncertainties of artificial intelligence and suffer the ills of inflation. Housing prices are out of reach. They are reluctant to marry and start families.

“It’s a huge phenomenon—the declining well-being of young working people,” says David Blanchflower, a Dartmouth economics professor. “There’s been a dramatic rise in their likelihood of despair and of ill mental health. The viability of their American Dream is at stake.”

The windfall that might save them is inheritance from the baby boomers, who started turning 80 this year. “Often called the Great Wealth Transfer, the inheritances are expected to be the largest passage of generational wealth in history, given the massive size of the baby boomer population and their wealth,” Rachel Lerman wrote in the Washington Post.

But there’s some doubt about the magnitude of the coming transfer—one report puts it at more than $100 trillion; another pegs it at only $36 trillion. The sum may be less than expected because baby boomers are living longer and spending more on themselves.

So what can Generation Z do? Take all this lamentation with a grain of salt. Maybe a tablespoon of it. We older folks have seen this before.

In 1982, Fran Schumer wrote “Downward Mobility,” a classic New York magazine cover story. She interviewed 20- and 30-somethings about their financial woes, classifying them as the nouveau pauvre, or, as a well-known economist put it, “well-dressed paupers.”

Ms. Schumer spoke to a married couple in New York whose $70,000 joint income (about $240,000 today) placed them “squarely in the comfortable middle class” but didn’t “allow them even to own their own home.” The husband complained that “so many of the amenities that seemed almost a birthright when he was growing up now appear to be out of reach.”

“The economic realities of adult life have come as a rude surprise to Mark and Alison Kramer”—not their real names—“and many others whose childhoods coincided with the great boom time of the fifties,” Ms. Schumer wrote. “A house, a car, staples of middle-class life, now seem like luxuries. The mention of a large suburban backyard is likely to evoke the same nostalgia from people in Manhattan as madeleines did for Proust in Remembrance of Things Past.”

The country was emerging from the Carter era of “malaise” and a decade of inflation, culminating in 20% interest rates in 1980 as Federal Reserve Chairman Paul Volcker tried to quash it. The stock market was in the doldrums. Accounting for inflation, Ms. Schumer speculated, workers would have to earn three times what their parents did to have the same purchasing power: “The economic frontier is closing fast on those who are least prepared to deal with it.”

Another New York couple were “swimming in degrees but are not convinced that they’ll end up living as comfortably as their parents did.” A young lawyer bemoaned his strained finances: “It’s not that I came from wealth; it’s just that I thought by the time I was 36 I’d easily be buying a second home, having a car.” He lived in a studio apartment on the East Side.

Because Ms. Schumer protected her interviewees’ identities with pseudonyms, we can’t know how these baby boomers did over the years. But in all likelihood they thrived and their wealth will contribute to the “Great Wealth Transfer.” The nouveau pauvre became the nouveau riche.

We know, more or less, how it happened. Volcker succeeded in reducing inflation, Ronald Reagan’s tax cuts kick-started the economy, the stock market surged, and the personal computer, internet and smartphone changed everyone’s lives.

It’s impossible to predict the future. Let’s not become prisoners of our ignorance. Prediction is a great game, but it’s only a game.

Read the original article on the Wall Street Journal’s website. By Jane Shaw Stroup.

John C. Goodman is President of the Goodman Institute and Senior Fellow at The Independent Institute. His books include the soon-to-be-published updated edition of Priceless: Curing the Healthcare Crisis, the widely acclaimed A Better Choice: Healthcare Solutions for America, and New Way to Care: Social Protections that Put Families First. The Wall Street Journal and National Journal, among other media, have called him the “Father of Health Savings Accounts.”

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *